Number 74, October 2003
  Injoy Stewardship Services 
    Baby Church or Small Church? 
    Leadership Network Thanks Its Resource Partners Who
Made Camp Improv Possible
 
Baby Church or Small Church?
by Russ Bredholt, Jr.

Even with an increasing number of church mergers and closings, new congregations continue to open on a consistent basis. Some of these new churches are even having very good days. The Lord is blessing evangelistic efforts through church planting.

Starting a church is never an easy task. It may be more difficult than starting a new business. We make this observation not second hand but from the experience of being involved with both types of ventures.

What is interesting, though, is how a church develops its identity, or what Quakers would refer to as, "true self."

"What an organization becomes is formed in its earliest days." So writes author William Bergquist in his book, "The Postmodern Organization." This is a simple but profound insight with implications for those who are sponsoring or starting churches.

There are many ways to begin. You can start a Bible study in someone's home or open with a strong core group coming out of an existing church. Whatever the approach, the track record for succeeding long-term is not good. The vast majority of new churches don't survive to their fifth birthday.

A key component of identity is this: Who or what decides whether a plant is a "baby church" (hoping to grow in size and strength) or a "small church" (capable of strength but with limited reach and programs)?

The question is not a judgment about "baby" versus "small." Rather, we want to probe this issue: How much thought should be given to shaping and influencing the future look of a church from the very beginning?

While most worshipers are in larger congregations, most churches are smaller in size. According to the Congregational Life Survey conducted in 2001, the average weekly attendance in the USA is about 90.

What then are some of the contributing factors in determining what kind of church it will be? Here is my list (feel free to make your own). . .
  • The spiritual leaders in the early days. It's the "who" that significantly shapes "what kind of church." Theology and philosophy (along with life's experiences) are underpinnings of strategy and design. How someone sees God, Scripture, the world, and community determines how they are likely to respond to the challenges and opportunities of ministry.

    Envisioning something (baby or small) comes from within the individuals who lead including clergy and laity. Both kinds of churches are needed and appropriate in the total mix. As Dr. Kennon Callahan points out, it's possible and sometimes desirable to be a "strong, small congregation."

    The genetic code (true self) gets inserted at the beginning and is difficult to alter. It doesn't get there by accident. It's put there by individuals and circumstances combined.

  • The methodologies. Approach is strategic and has much to do with outcomes. Methodologies are plentiful but they can't always be replicated. The one method, however, that is available to all congregations regardless of size and location is follow-up.

    The one way to build credible relationships with new people is to do what you say you are going to do. Promise less and deliver more.

    There are many benefits that accrue to those who pay attention to detail. Unfortunately, most churches don't seem disposed toward this end.

    How implementation and follow through are initially handled sets the tone and culture for the church in a positive or negative way.

  • The marketplace. There are times when the setting plays a decided role in what a church becomes. As someone once said, "geography and demography are destiny." This statement may be stretching to make a point but it's a reality more often than not.

    Communities often defy conventional wisdom. Rural areas and smaller towns can often be found with a large, strong congregation. And we know there are a fair amount of baby churches planted in growing areas that never take off.

    More than the size of the community or neighborhood is the makeup of the populous. A church may fit or not. Even with the capable leaders and resources, sometimes the plant and the area are a mismatch. Someone failed to do their homework.

    Growing communities do not automatically mean success for baby churches. Yet this is where a large number of baby churches begin--and succeed.

  • The "mysteries of God." In the Gospel of Mark 4:26-27, Jesus speaks the parable of the growing seed.

    ". . . The kingdom of God is as if a man should scatter seed on the ground, and should sleep by night and rise by day, and the seed should sprout and grow, he himself does not know how."

    Results tend to be a combination of three things--faith, work and mystery. The emergent is why we have to leave room in our best laid plans for the "mysteries of God."

    Sometimes churches get off to a slow start. After years of struggle and persistent commitment, it's possible to see things take off. How this happens is more mystery than some stroke of genius on the part of a leader. Ask a church planting pastor who crosses the great divide how it happened. Those with some measure of humility will say they are unable to explain their situation.

    Jesus said this would be so.
Baby or small, we need new congregations that are spiritually strong and viable in ministry. It's essential in order to complete the work of Christ.

Russ Bredholt, Jr. is a management consultant and member of the Editors Board at Leadership Network. He can be reached at rbredholt@aol.com.


BACK TO EXPLORER

Leadership Network - 2501 Cedar Springs, Suite 200 - Dallas, Texas 75201 - Tel: 800.765.5323 or 214.969.5950